Letters to the Editor

Dear Editor,

Your feature article, “Biological Approach to Bipolar Mood Disorder”, describes Bipolar Disorder from an intense biological approach. It is very one sided, and therefore it would be refreshing to show an alternate approach. I believe a psychodynamic approach best describes an unconscious conflict people with bipolar disorder face. This theory shows that dynamics of manic and depression are linked in a common pathway. Depression is a manifestation of losses of self-esteem or self worth, therefore mania serves as a depression defense. Also, if the twin studies really proves that bipolar disorder is genetic, then both identical twins would develop the illness 100% of the time if one twin has the illness.

Sincerely,

FreudFanGirl123

Dear Editor,

            Your view does not take into account individual will power and the ultimate truth, which is that we all have a destiny in our lives… and that is self-actualization.  Everyone has the ability to solve our own personal issues. We grow and thrive psychologically in environments conducive to our lifestyles, and the futures we choose for ourselves. There are no unconscious forces working against us, because ultimately, we have complete control over ourselves. If one grows up with limited positive regard, without a stable role model, and a limited amount of social interaction, they are not likely to thrive healthily, and are, therefore, more susceptible to bipolar disorder. In order to treat this disorder, a non-judgmental environment is essential, a self-directed way of recovery. More specifically, goals are to get the bipolar patient taking their medication consistently, being able to differentiate between their actual versus their idealized selves, keep friendships steady. In the long run, a patient will be able to become more aware of one’s self, more comfortable socially and able to rely on themselves for evaluation of their worth. An environment in which maladaptive thinking is discouraged.

-TreeHugger420

Dear Editor,

        Although you provide evidence towards an approach of bipolar disorder being biological, I believe it can be treated seen by more of an cognitive-behavioral approach. Even though biological factors are present in bipolar disorder are not acted alone and are nor favorable in action with stress. Thoughts actually influence mood and can have negative results due to emotional distress that appear immensely in bipolar disorder. With therapy, cognitive-behavioral skills are used as an aid with individuals to manage their bipolar disorder. These skills involve balanced behavioral routines including but not limited to sleeping and eating, as well as recognition of mood shifts and management of depression and suicidal thoughts and behaviors.

Love Cognitive-Behavioral is Key